Saturday, October 25, 2008

The financial crisis - in a way even YOU can understand

pokemon

Everybody knows about the financial crisis the world is going through, but I am sure at least some of you don't really understand why it all started, right?

Well the following article explains exactly how it all started in a way even a 14 year old 'pokemon' fan girl can understand.

Enjoy - The article

Wednesday, October 22, 2008

The American debt clock

debt_clock_1014

The American debt is basically the amount of money owed by the American government to U.S debt instruments, such as treasury bills, bonds etc. You can read more about it here.

As of three weeks ago, the American debt passed the 10 trillion $ (!!!) mark. The interesting thing is that the American debt clock in Times Square, which shows the current debt, was not built to hold such huge numbers. As you can see in the picture, the $ sign now also holds the tens of trillions digit. Try this out for more insights.

If this recession will last as long as expected, the debt will probably increase much more, and there will be no other option but to build another clock, with a few more digits...

Saturday, September 27, 2008

Amazing 20 questions on the Internet

Everybody knows the game "20 questions" in which someone chooses a figure (real or fiction) and the others need to guess who the figure is using only 20 right or wrong questions. Adapting it to the Internet looks trivial - all you need is a database of figures and questions. I already did something similar about 25 years ago, trying to guess an animal that my father/mother picked (in Basic!!!).

Well actually it is not that trivial - you need to have a very big database and find the correct questions to ask to be able to divide the vast information quickly enough so that you are able to guess the correct figure after only 20 questions.

                              image

Akinator (http://www.devinettor.com/#) does it incredibly well! I played it about 10 times until I succeeded to win (meaning he couldn't guess my figure, which by the way was Doug from the time tunnel...). In the homepage you can see the last 10 games it played, and it seems that the statistics are almost always 9 to 1 (i.e. 9 out of 10 games, Akinator succeeds).

                   image

You can also view the top characters that were picked from the beginning of the web site. Interestingly, this web site is played mostly by Israeli's - Bar Refaeli, Ninet Tayeb and Tzipi Livni are all in the top 10 ever... Apart from them you have You, your mother and Akinator, the 'always click on yes', 'always click on no' and 'always click on don't know'. The only non Israeli and actual named figure is Angelina Jolie. Interesting. Could it be that Brad Pit also plays here often?...

Saturday, September 20, 2008

43.7

מה חשב לעצמו שאול מופז? כל אחד מאיתנו שאל את עצמו אתהשאלה הזו בשבוע האחרון. מילא לנבא שתנצח (הרי צריך להחדיר רוח קרב ואופטימיות) אבל למה לנבא בכמה? מה הסיכוי שמופז יקבל בדיוק 43.7 אחוזים מהבוחרים?

43.7

והנה, לאחר קבלת תוצאות האמת מסתבר שמופז לא היה רחוק כל כך. אולי זה אומר שאפשר להתנבא על 43.7 אחוז ולהיות מאד קרוב? בוא ננסה...

43.7

אני אומר שהסיכוי שארה"ב תבחר נשיא שחור הוא 43.7 אחוז. נשמע הגיוני, לא? אני גם חושב שהסיכוי שלבני לא תצליח להקים ממשלה ואנחנו עומדים בפני בחירות הוא 43.7. כמו כן, הסיכוי שמכבי תל אביב בכדורסל לא תיקח השנה את כל התארים בישראל הוא 43.7. בוא'נה - זה ממש כיף העניין הזה של להתנבא. אף אחד לא יכול לסתור אותך וכל מה שתגיד יהיה נכון באותה מידה שהוא לא נכון.

43.7

גאון המופז הזה...

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Beware - email

If you are reading this post from an email - then I am sorry, I didn't mean to disturb. But since you are already concentrating on this, then keep on reading.

emailIcon

What was I doing just now?

The Sidney Morning Herald paper has published the conclusions of a research that was done in the UK, among which it was discovered that it takes roughly 64 seconds on average for someone to get back to what he was doing before a new email has popped into his inbox.

So how much time do we spend on emails?

The meaning of this is that for people who check their inbox every 5 minutes, will waste more than 8 hours a week wondering what they were doing seconds before they got an email... Think about it - 20% of the time spent at work is spent on thinking "hell, what was I doing a minute ago?". If you add to this another minute of reading and replying to emails, you get more than 50% wasted on moving into and from your inbox.

How much time does it take to reply to a message?

It was also discovered that although emails are thought to be non disturbing (especially compared to the annoying messengers), people tend to reply to emails 1 minute and 44 seconds, on average, after a new email was received.

What can we do about it?

One very simple thing is not to have an icon displayed (and of course not to have anything popping up) when an email has arrived. This small thing can lead into the ability to work without the interference of emails, at least not when you are concentrating on a specific task.

But what can we do about phone calls, SMS, messenger and calling my name in the hallway?

Maybe I will have a second post on this, depends on how much I get disturbed...

Riddle 7 - Glass balls

ball

Here we go again - audience participation time! Yes, it's time for a new riddle. As usual, we will first review the solution to the riddle before. The solution is very basic - you just need to count the numbers from left to right... Each time we simply write down the number of appearances of the digit and the digit itself. For example, let's take the one before last row:

4 2 1 3 1 1

The first digit is 4, how many appearances? 1. Therefore we write 1 4
Now 2 which appears once, therefore 1 2
Now 1 which appears 3 times, 3 1 and last 1 3. So the result is:

1 4 1 2 3 1 1 3

The next row will be:
4 1 1 4 1 2 2 3, which is almost what Alex has wrote...


Riddle 7 - glass balls

glass_ball

Imagine you have a single glass ball and a 100 stories high building. You want to know what is the highest story from which you can throw the ball and still it will not shatter. Since you have only one ball, you must start from the first floor and go up one by one, or else you might find yourself with a shattered ball and no idea of the exact floor from which you can throw balls (if you had any...) and still admire the view...


So if I ask you how many trials you need in the worst case, the answer is 100. You can't do better.

But what if you had 2 balls? What is the minimal number of trials, worst case, that you need to do to find the exact spot?

What about 3 balls? 4 balls? Is there a pattern here?

Sunday, September 14, 2008

The power of the blog

The internet has brought to our lives many beautiful things, such as googling and wikiing (if the verb wiki is not yet in use - well it's about time...), on-line shopping (see my new Toshiba) and of course blogging. You probably know what I am talking about (since you are reading this blog - which means you do take part in the new internet community), but have you ever wondered how much do these blogs affect our lives?

Well the following story will probably change your prespective. 

Everybody knows today who is Sarah Palin - the nominee for vice president of the republicans. If the worst-case scenario of the democrats comes to life, she will be the 45th president of the United States (and the first female president) after McCain will fall sick and will not be able to continue his presidency. But do you know how she got there? Well meet Adam Brickley. Adam is a 21 years old republican from Colarado who has never met Palin but has decided, on February 2007, way before anyone new who are going to be the nominees for presidency, that Sarah Palin should be the nominee for vice president. What did he do about this you ask? He opened a blog... http://palinforvp.blogspot.com/ According to the american press, his blog is the source from which Palin's name has come up in McCain's list for nominees. Apparently, Palin herself has phoned Brickley and thanked him for his efforts and help to become the next vice president of the United States (unless Obama somehow turns this all around - which seems to me unlikely).

So it seems that a blog can do a whole lot, doesn't it?

If Brickley can nominee a vice president - maybe I can do something about the Kadima elections? Why not?
Well - I am for Tzipi Livni, and if she does indeed get elected and become the next prime minister of Israel - you all know where you read it for the first time... :-)

Saturday, September 6, 2008

How to find your favorite song

Songza is the place to look for any video clip or song you want to hear.
Its search engine enables you to look for a name of a song, of an artist or even a partial line within the song.

Once you found the songs you are looking for, you can watch their video, listen to them, buy them, share them, rate them or add them to your playlist - basically anything you'de want to do with a song...
One nice feature that makes this site stronger than searching in youtube is the ability to search while listening to the last song you've found.


As this is a music related post, I couldn't end it without a song or two from Genesis.
This is one of my favorites - the second part of Home By The Sea from the "Genesis" album in 1983.



Another great song is Firth of Fifth from their 1973 album - Selling England by the Pound:





Enjoy!

Friday, September 5, 2008

Kindle - Amazon's e-book




What is kindle?
Kindle is Amazon's digital or e-book. Kindle can replace hundreds of books, making it a very "green" product.

What's the big deal? You can read everything on the laptop?
Yes you can, but Kindle is much lighter, does not need to connect to Wi-Fi to get updates or download and has a screen specifically designed for reading. I don't know about you, but I get really tired after a few minutes of reading on my computer.



Currently, you can download books from Amazon, paying as less as 10$ for a best seller. One of the better offers of Kindle is that you don't pay for the connection/downloads. You only pay for the right to download the book.





So?
The interesting question is whether this e-book (or one of his descendants) will be able to do to regular books what the digital camera did to film camera and what the Wikipedia is doing to regular encyclopedias. It will not be a big surprise if our children will go to school with a single Kindle, holding all materials for all lessons. That's certainly much better than our sour backs from the heavy bags we had to carry around...


Riddle 6 - Numbers numbers... hint

A hint to the sixth riddle - count!

As I said, any small child who knows to count can solve this puzzle...

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

New Chrome Browser from Google




The new Google Chrome is out! This is a new browser from Google, which is going to battle against Internet Explorer and Firefox. Last time Google and Microsoft were battling, Google came on top with superior search engines. The interesting question now is whether Google will be able to take the lead against Microsoft's Internet Explorer.

Chrome promises better performance, better integration with applications such as Gmail and Google Docs (obviously) and features coming from all known browsers. You can read more about it in the Chrome comics http://www.google.com/googlebooks/chrome/#

This is how my blog looks like from Chrome:

When I tried to access my hotmail account throught Chrome, I got the following warning:

Upgrade your web browser

We recommend that you upgrade your web browser so you can get the most out of Windows Live Hotmail. Upgrading should only take a few minutes. To get started, choose one of the browsers below:
If you don’t want to upgrade right now you can still continue to Windows Live Hotmail, but some parts of it may not work and it may not be displayed properly.
Could it be that this is how Microsoft is dealing with the new rival?

Summary of the first day (it just came out yesterday) - very promising, but need to be further explored.

Tuesday, September 2, 2008

Plasma or LCD? I have decided


It was time to decide: plasma or LCD? My decision is not an academic one, and I cannot and don't want to convince you to do the same.

I chose LCD. Specifically, I chose this TV. The picture in the beginning is of my new TV screen.
Why? well the price was OK, Toshiba is a well known manufacturer and this TV is quite new. Why LCD? No definite answer here, but I can say that there are much more options in LCD than in Plasma, and that could be the reason I tended to go to this direction.
Anyway, if you haven't decided yet - good luck.
I'm done, at least for the next couple of years, I hope...

Friday, August 29, 2008

Riddle 6 - Numbers numbers...

And here we go again - another riddle.

But first - what's the solution to the last riddle http://omer-behindthelines.blogspot.com/2008/08/riddle-5-doorway-to-heaven.html? The answer is that you should always pick the door that was left behind and not the door you originally picked. This is because there was a 33% chance for you to be right in the first place, meaning that there was a 66% that the right door is one of the other two doors. Since the gnome has helped you to throw away one of these two doors, all the 66% chance went to the door he left behind. So there is a bigger chance that that door is the correct one.

Riddle 6 - what is the next number?
Look carefully at the following list of numbers and please write down the next one to follow:
1
1 1
2 1
1 2 1 1
3 1 1 2
1 3 2 1 1 2
3 1 1 3 2 2
2 3 2 1 2 2
4 2 1 3 1 1
1 4 1 2 3 1 1 3
???

One small hint - no need for mathematics at all, a 8 year old kid can solve this...

Saturday, August 23, 2008

The McGurk Effect

What is the man in the next video saying?



Did you hear "Da Da"? Try again, this time without watching the video, only listening... This is called the McGurk effect.

In this video the phenomenon is explained:




Interesting, isn't it?
You can read more about it in here McGurk effect .


Thanks Moran and Yaron for the very interesting item.

Tuesday, August 19, 2008

Have you heard about the Mojave experiment?


When I first heard about this, I couldn't think about anything but the Matrix ("Do you know what's the Matrix?") or the "Dharma initiative" from Lost. Well, it has nothing to do with either of them. Basically it is just another commercial of Microsoft for the notorious Windows Vista.






So what's it all about? Microsoft claims to have done the following experiment: They interviewed more than a hundred non-Vista users that have heard about Vista and did not like what they heard. They were asked to grade Vista (giving an overall 4.4 grade on average). Then they were shown "the next Microsoft OS" codenamed "Mojave". Most of them were very impressed and liked what they saw and gave the overall 8.5 grade on average. It was then they were told that actually what they saw was Vista and nothing else.






I said Microsoft claims this. I am not accusing Microsoft of anything, but it is still a commercial and probably not a lot more. You can see for yourself in http://www.mojaveexperiment.com/




And now the punch line – looking at the website and at all the screens shown (as seen above) does again make me think about "the Dharma initiative" – so maybe there is more here than meets the eye?!?







A house in Detroit was baught for 1$


Believe it or not, a house in Detroit was recently bought for 1$ (not 1 million dollars, 1 dollar)!

Just two years ago the same house was bought for 65,000$, and for the last 19 days the house was for sale for 1$ until it found a buyer.

How come? Well first of all this house is near the airport in Detroit in a poor neighborhood. Second, you probably already guessed it - the owner could not pay the mortgage and the house was taken by the bank. The bank tried to sell it since January for 1,100$ but could not find anyone interested. During this time the property started to owe debts in the size of 4,000$ and the bank decided to lower the price for 1$.

There is more. After the original owners of the house were evicted, steel thieves stole all they could from the property, including the sinks. When the bank asked a guarding company to guard the property, they put some wooden boards to protect it, but these were stolen too...


Seems like this house does not have a very promising ending.


The full (in Hebrew) article can be found here: http://www.themarker.com/tmc/article.jhtml?ElementId=nh20080817_06

Tuesday, August 12, 2008

21


Yesterday I saw the movie "21" with Kevin Spacey. In the beginning of the movie he asks a student of his a riddle, which is exactly the same as riddle #5 (only with a different story). The answer gave in the movie is correct - so you can copy it if you'de like.
P.S. I didn't like the film - everything was too obvious...

Monday, August 11, 2008

Riddle 5 - doorway to heaven

It's time for a new riddle, but let's first solve the last one.

How many times do you need to break the chocolate bar to get 24 sqauares? Well I am going to show you that it doesn't matter how you break it, it will always be 23 times. How come? the simple fact is that every time you break a piece of the bar, you actually add another piece to your collection (breaking a bar creates two parts of that bar). So, if you start with 1 piece - the whole bar - then after exactly 23 breaks you will have 24 pieces - exactly the 24 squares of chocolate we wanted.


Doorway to heaven

You are standing in front of three doors.


You know that one door leads to heaven, while the other two lead to hell. You have no way of knowing which is which, and running out of time, you pick one (doesn't matter which one) and go towards it.

Suddenly there appears a gnome.


He sees that you were going to open the door you picked and says:

"I know which door leads to heaven and which don't. Believe me when I say that this door is a door to hell" and while he is saying that, he is pointing to one of the other two doors (and not to the door you chose).

The gnome tells the truth (it doesn't matter which door you picked in the first place, he will always have a door that he can point out that leads to hell), so the door he pointed out is out of the question.

The riddle is: which door should you choose now? The door you chose in the first place, or the door that the gnome has left out of the two?

There is no right door or wrong door, but maybe there is a difference in the probability between the two?

Sunday, August 10, 2008

Plasma or LCD?

I currently have a 29 inch CRT TV at home. I think it's time for an upgrade - a 42 inch flat screen.

But is it a real upgrade? Every time I walk into a shop, all the screens look unclear and blurry. Is that what's the future holds for us? Blurry pictures? I hope not.

Let's assume not - that a 42inch flat screen is indeed an upgrade. Now I need to pick my choice out of literally hundreds of choices.

First choice is LCD of Plasma. I have read a lot about the differences but haven't yet decided what is best for me. To tell the truth, I can't even tell the difference in appearance between the two - can you?



Which of the above pictures is an LCD and which is Plasma? Difficult to say, isn't it?

Here is a movie trying to answer the question - Plasma or LCD?


Even if I did decide which of the technologies I am going for, there are too many parameters to look at to decide which specific module will get the privilege to get into my saloon. One solution to this is to get advice from a professional - but I always have the feeling I am being hassled. Maybe that's why the movie below was created - to guide you towards buying a flat screen in Israel:

If you can't see the movie from here, you can go directly to http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-7379854967753847285&hl=en

So what to do? Maybe you can help?! If you have an opinion, please let me know by commenting or voting in the poll.

Thanks anyway...

Thursday, August 7, 2008

The Dark Knight


As I promised, here is my thoughts on "The Dark Knight" - the latest Batman movie. I am not going to reveal anything critical if you haven't seen the movie yet - and I urge you to see it.

A few days ago I had lunch with a couple of friends. We all saw the movie seperately and wanted to discuss it. The notion that Batman did not have the leading part in the movie, like all comic films are built, was agreed on everyone. One of my friends even said that he could not sympathise with Batman since he wasn't as important in the movie as his evil counterpart - the joker. We then understood that he didn't yet see the first "new" movie Batman - "Batman Begins". This was probably why he could not understand Batman and could not identify with him.

I also read a lot of articles from critics, stating that this movie is better (or much better) than the earlier one. I tend to partially agree - I do see why they would think it is a more meaningful film, but I think that it doesn't hold without its origin. "The Dark Knight" should not stand on its own. I think it is very important to first see "Batman Begins" in order to understand the new concept of Batman and enjoy the new blockbuster.

In the past, I didn't understand how come people could mention Superman, Spiderman and Batman in the same sentence. Superman and Spiderman are "real" super heroes whereas Batman is just a rich fellow with no special abilities what so ever. The new series of Batman movies had changed all that. Batman may not be a super hero like others, but he is definately a hero as well as a great fiction figure.

Tuesday, August 5, 2008

Curse on the dark knight?

I was about to publish a post about "The Dark Knight" (and I will) when I read in the news about Morgan Freeman's accident. He is in bad condition hospitalized and I am crossing my fingures he will make it out.

So, is there a curse on the dark knight? Heath Ledger dies of accidental overdose of prescription drugsChristian Bale was arrested for hitting his mother and now Morgan.

Is someone behind all these accidents?
Could it be, the joker?

יאאאאניבבבבב


אני משער שרובנו מכירים את החוויה של משחק קלפים משעשע במקום אקזוטי ברחבי הגלובוס. תאילנד, נפאל, הודו ואפילו במערב - בכל מקום בו תמצאו צעירים ישראלים, קרוב לוודאי שגם תשמעו את קריאת הניצחון "יאאאניבבבבב!!!" בשלב זה או אחר. ובכן עכשיו יוצא המשחק (המפגר מה אם יורשה לי לומר) כמשחק משווק לכל דבר, להלן "סופר יניב". אני רק מקווה שלא הפכו את המשחק האינפנטילי גם כך למשחק טיפשי עוד יותר. תהנו

Sunday, August 3, 2008

Cuil vs. Google (#2)

Continuing the comparison between the two search engines, here is a small experiment I made trying to find pictures for chocolates (I needed them for the new riddle - http://omer-behindthelines.blogspot.com/2008/08/riddle-4-piece-of-chocolate.html).


I typed in "chocolate pictures" in both search engines and clicked on the first link I was given.


The results

In Google I got the following page:

















In Cuil, they must have thought I was referring to a horse named 'chocolate':





Chocolate Pictures


2:0 to Google, and I think that Cuil might have a great way of handling requests with much less hardware - but they must improve their engine for the end-user to find anything relative.

Friday, August 1, 2008

Riddle 4 - a piece of chocolate




It's time for the next riddle, but before that, let's examine the last one (http://omer-behindthelines.blogspot.com/2008/07/riddle-3-ants-everywhere.html). Alex suggested that it will not take more than 2 minutes for the ants to fall off. The fact is that it will take 1 minute, maximal, for all the ants to fall. The way to prove this is to take a look at what happens when two ants meet (see illustration below). As I said, each ant turns around instantly and goes back to the direction it came from. However, since ants have no names and ant #1 is, for the sake of the riddle, just the same as ant #2, we can imagine that instead of turning around, each ant replaces places with the ant that it met and continues in its journey. Taking this into account, it is obvious that each ant, no matter how many ants it meets in its way, will go in one direction until it drops off - meaning that all the ants will drop after at the most 1 minute.


Riddle 4

In this riddle we have a bar of chocolate. This bar has 6 columns and 4 rows of chocolate, making 24 squares or pieces of chocolate.

The question is - how many times, minimal, do I need to break the bar until I get 24 separate pieces of chocolate (assuming that each break is along a line that separates between two rows or columns and there is no additional breaks)? Please explain why your answer is the lowest number of breaks that can actually give the wanted result.

Thursday, July 31, 2008

Cuil vs. Google (#1)

Whilst Google were working on the new internet encyclopedia Knol to counter the leader - Wikipedia, a different company were working on a new search engine and website Cuil to counter the leadership of Google in that area. Were Google blind-sided? Maybe, but as you will see, Google does not yet have a real rival in the search engine territory.

So what is Cuil?
Cuil is a new search engine that challenges Google at the operation level - the number of hardware needed to keep the engine alive is much less than the enormous power needed for Google. But does that interest the user searching for something - probably not. The user is interested in finding what he was looking for, as high in the results as possible. I made some tests to see how good is the new engine, you can review the results below.

User interface differences
Cuil does have a few UI (user interface) differences:

1) The homepage is somewhat of the opposite to the white-empty Google page


2) The results are shown in a few columns, as opposed to the list view of Google


The results

1) I tried to search my own name - I know it can be looked at some kind of an ego trip but actually it's a very valid test. As you can see below, Cuil does not know me at all!! Very sad indeed.


2) I tried to see what I get when searching for "Hapoel Tel Aviv" (my home soccer team). The Google matching was right to the point, whereas the Cuil results were not so good.


All in all, it is 1:0 to the Google.

Wednesday, July 30, 2008

Knol vs. Wikipedia (#3)

Apparently I am not the only one making comparison tests between the two (not that I thought I was). TheMarker's Captain Digital himself has done his own testing and arrived to the same conclusion as I did – Wikipedia wins, at least for now.


By the way, the two articles that are the same in both websites is not because they were written by the same person (like the author of this article assumes) but because they were actually copied from Wikipedia to Knol (just like Israel's article was copied, twice).

Does this mean it's 2-0 for Wikipedia? Well yes. These tests were different from the tests I have done, which gives an additional advantage to the Wiki.

The full article (in hebrew) can be found here: http://it.themarker.com/tmit/article/4100

Monday, July 28, 2008

Riddle 3 - a hint

A hint for the ants riddle - an ant has no name.
Think about it...

The Wikipedia Game

Speaking about Wikipedia, here is a video clip about a game you can play with it.
You can skip the first 20-25 seconds where the girl jumps around and go straight to the explanation about the game.
Basically it's something like the six degrees of seperation (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Six_degrees_of_separation) - your goal is to get from one random article to another using only internal links of Wikipedia. It will be interesting if this can be done by up to 6 steps (following the six degrees argument).
I haven't tried this before, but it does look addictive.
Best of luck.

Sunday, July 27, 2008

Knol vs. Wikipedia (#2)

Continuing the comparison between the two, here is a small test I ran today. After seeing huge differences between Knol's reaction to 'Genesis' (which apart from the rock band, is just the first bible book... ;-) and Wikipedia's massive information regarding the subject, I wanted to see how they deal with a subject such as 'Israel'.

I chose Israel, first because it is a country (my country) and should be well known by both giants. Secondly - it is an interesting subject because of its subjectivity. One of the problems in Wikipedia is that it should be impartial. A subject such as Israel is could create many conflicts between different people with different opinions and someone must decide how the article about such a subject will turn out, objectively as possible. In Knol, there is no problem with such a subject, since the entries are credited and you can judge an entry looking at its author.


The results:
In Wikipedia, the article about Israel has a lot of information, most of it hard facts. The article was edited and modified several times (you can see the evolution in the "discussion" page).


In Knol I found not less than 4 entries named Israel, and we are talking about a website that has just became public. This, I think, is one of the drawbacks of Knol. Since it is credited and one cannot edit an entry of another, you can simply add your own entry of the same subject, making it difficult to read everything and get the "true story". How many entries named Israel do you think are going to be in a few months - I guess a lot. Secondly - at least two of the entries were exactly the same - both copied from the article in Wikipedia. Well - that was predictable. Again his is somewhat problematic - anyone can take credit of an entry he copied from somewhere else, and even gain some profit from it by adding some ads. Doesn't sound so good, does it?


Summary:


Well, in this test Wikipedia took 1st place. I don't see how duplicated entries are better than the source, and come to think of it - who guarantees that a modification in the Israel article in Wikipedia will find it's rightful place in Knol?

1:0 to Wiki, still counting.

Saturday, July 26, 2008

Knol vs. Wikipedia (#1)

Google has released recently (23rd July) a competitor to Wikipedia (http://www.wikipedia.org/) called Knol (http://knol.google.com/). I think it will be interesting to follow up on the competition between the two, both aiming to "rule over knowledge of man kind".



I'll begin my comparison between them with a few dry facts. I will let you be the judges (I will write my opinion at a later post)


Is it free?
  • Wikipedia is free and ad-free. There is no intent to gain financial profit from this project.


  • Knol is free but not ad-free. The main incentive to write in Knol is that you might get money from your published work by adding ads.

Anonymous vs. credit

  • You can write anonymously in Wikipedia. The articles themselves are anonymous/credit less.


  • I am not sure you can write anonymously in knol - it does ask for your user name when you try to create a new article. The articles themselves are with credits - you can see exactly who wrote them. This is part of the idea of being able to get some profit out of this.

Editing articles

  • In Wikipedia, anyone can edit an existing article, fixing any mistakes or enhancing any part.


  • Knol does not let you edit work that you have not published yourself.

For now I will leave you with an interesting comparison between both knowledge bases on the word "genesis". I know it is not a fair comparison, since knol was just released, but it is still a bit amusing to see the difference:




Wednesday, July 23, 2008

Trading places


No - this is not a post on the very funny film by John Landis (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0086465/).


The article at the bottom talks about people going abroad, that instead of paying for a room in some hotel, they switch their apartment with some people going the opposite direction. This is a very interesting concept. The most obvious reason is that this can reduce the budget of a trip abroad by some very large extent – the example given in the article is that an ordinary hotel room in NYC costs about 250 dollars for a couple. A 10 day vacation in the big apple living in someone else's apartment means about 2500 dollars savings. Moreover, an apartment is usually located in a less touristic, more interesting location, and may have better accommodations, a laundry machine, a bigger TV and so on and so forth…


The table above shows some of the more popular sites that allow people to find a switching partner.




How do you find an apartment to switch with? The Internet makes this very easy. There are several websites offering a service of connecting two people to switch their home for a limited time. This looks like a great solution for someone that cannot afford hotel prices or just prefers to feel at home even when he is away.


This is an example of a post in CraigsList.com asking for a switch between Berlin and Tel-Aviv (how I wish I had heard about this a month ago - Berlin was lovely, but I am sure a german apartment, for free, would have been a much more interesting surrounding than the nice but ordinary hotel room we took):




But what are the chances of me, finding someone from New York, who wants to be in Israel, or better yet, in Hertzelya for the exact time that I want to have my vacation in Manhattan? Does this mean I need to wait for a miracle in which someone chooses my apartment to spend his vacation in and then fly away to wherever he is coming from?


Manhattan sky line - is there anyone in the picture that wants to be my house switch partner?

What do you think about another option – instead of switching places between two people, why not have a circular transition? I will go to New York, the woman from NY will visit Rome, the Italian guy will have a nice apartment in Brazil, and Ronaldinio junior will stay at my place? This cannot be done manually of course, but a simple enough algorithm can try to give everyone the vacation they are dreaming about without going bankrupt.

The original article (in hebrew) can be found here: http://www.themarker.com/tmc/article.jhtml?ElementId=skira20080723_1004603&origin=ibo&strToSearch=%E3%E9%F8%E4%2C%EC%E4%E7%EC%E9%F3